Unfortunate Bob Dylan followers who spent $599 to purchase 900 personally “hand-signed” copies of his new e-book “The Philosophy of Trendy Tune” will get refunds after writer Simon & Schuster admitted to complaints Sunday afternoon. the signatures truly counted as mechanical duplicates.
“To those that bought the restricted version ‘Philosophy of Trendy Tune,’ we want to apologize,” stated a tweet from Simon & Schuster, which put the books up on the market on its web site. “Clearly, the restricted version books have Bob’s unique signature, however within the type of a written reproduction. We’re correcting this info by issuing a right away refund to every purchaser.”
The books started arriving in patrons’ mailboxes on Friday, and patrons shortly started evaluating notes — or, extra importantly, images — and realized the books had been apparently signed utilizing “autopen,” which captures and reproduces an actual signature. machine pushed pen. Patrons sharing images on public boards had been in a position to determine these utilizing 17 totally different signature variants as of Sunday night, earlier than the writer acknowledged the gadgets weren’t as marketed.
On Friday, the writer denied requests for a refund of the $599 worth, arguing that the books had been nonetheless hand-signed, as acknowledged in a letter from the corporate head that accompanied every quantity, verifying his doc. authenticity These preliminary responses learn: “We definitely perceive your issues, nevertheless – every restricted version copy of Bob Dylan’s THE PHILOSOPHY OF MODERN SONG is personally signed by the writer and comes with a letter of authenticity from the writer. Simon & Schuster “.
Everybody who acquired a purchase order acquired a letter signed by Jonathan Karp, President and CEO, stating that “you’re holding one thing very particular, certainly one of solely 900 copies accessible within the US.” “This letter is to verify that the copy of the e-book you’re holding has been hand-signed by Bob Dylan.”
However inside 48 hours, with photographic proof suggesting the declare was unlikely to be true, the corporate modified its tune. Emails that started to be despatched to complaining prospects early Sunday afternoon referred to a “mistake”: “We apologize for the error and are providing a full refund to your buy. Please maintain your copy of ‘The Philosophy of Trendy Tune’ at no cost. Learn We hope you take pleasure in it,” reads the e-mail, additionally signed by Karp.
The usage of the Autopen is commonly wanted—and, in fact, not universally frowned upon—within the collector world, with many celebrities accused of utilizing it, although not often signed gadgets promote for $600 or extra.
It’s unlikely that Simon & Schuster intentionally misled patrons when the duplicates had been so simply noticed, resulting in hypothesis as to why the corporate thought the books had been individually signed. Previously, Dylan has supplied autographed limited-edition copies of his paintings or his “Chronicles” e-book, and eagle-eyed followers usually imagine that the majority or all the earlier gadgets had been hand-signed.
Representatives for the writer didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark Sunday.
On eBay, sellers supplied the “signed” e-book for resale for $6,000 over the weekend. Most of those listings have been eliminated, both by the sellers or eBay itself. However some are hoping the e-book will nonetheless be a collectible: Shortly after Simon & Schuster’s launch got here out, an eBay vendor was itemizing an “autoopen hardcover” for $725.
An Autograph Dwell web page offered a gathering place for collectors to check notes on Dylan’s signatures because the books arrived within the mail, together with images of the 17 variations patrons had seen by Sunday.
“Philosophy of Trendy Tune” has acquired excessive reward since its launch earlier this month, amongst others The variabilityreferred to as the e-book “a blast”.